Trump Ex-Allies Suddenly Join Call for His Removal: “He’s Gone Insane”
As
even some of Trump’s former top MAGA supporters start admitting he’s
unfit, Jennifer Rubin of The Contrarian explains how we can keep the
removal talk on the front burner.
Celal Gunes/Anadolu/Getty Images
Donald Trump’s deranged threat to obliterate Iranian civilization entirely has prompted powerful pushback from some former MAGA allies. Some are suggesting it’s time to invoke the Twenty-Fifth Amendment to remove him, including Alex Jones, Anthony Scaramucci, and Marjorie Taylor Greene, who tweeted that “he has gone insane.” Tucker Carlson called on military officials not to follow illegal orders to attack civilian infrastructure. After we recorded, Trump temporarily postponed
the assault. But the conversation about his unfitness has been
reopened. We talked to Jennifer Rubin, editor in chief of The Contrarian
and author of a good piece on Trump’s vow of genocide.
We discuss the gravity of Trump’s war-crime threats, the cowardice of
Republicans who keep enabling this madman, and how we can keep the
removal talk alive. Listen to this episode here. A transcript is here.
Trump’s
announcement of the ceasefire agreement came less than two hours before
the US president’s self-imposed 8pm Eastern time deadline to bomb
Iran’s power plants and bridges in a move that legal scholars, as well
as officials from numerous countries and the pope, had warned could
constitute war crimes.
Just hours earlier,
Trump had written on Truth Social: “A whole civilization will die
tonight, never to be brought back again. I don’t want that to happen,
but it probably will.” American B-52 bombers were reported to be en
route to Iran before the ceasefire agreement was announced.
But
by Tuesday evening, Trump announced that a ceasefire agreement had been
mediated through Pakistan, whose prime minister, Shehbaz Sharif, had
requested the two-week peace in order to “allow diplomacy to run its
course”.
Trump wrote in a post that “subject
to the Islamic Republic of Iran agreeing to the COMPLETE, IMMEDIATE, and
SAFE OPENING of the Strait of Hormuz, I agree to suspend the bombing and attack of Iran for a period of two weeks”.
In
a separate post later, the US president called Tuesday “a big day for
world peace” on a social media post, claiming that Iran had “had
enough”. He said the US would be “helping with the traffic buildup” in
the strait of Hormuz and that “big money will be made” as Iran begins
reconstruction.
For several hours afterwards,
Israel’s position or agreement with the deal was unclear. But just
before midnight ET, the prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu,
said Israel backed the US ceasefire with Iran but that the deal did not
cover fighting against Hezbollah in Lebanon. His office said Israel
also supported US efforts to ensure Iran no longer posed a nuclear or
missile threat.
Pakistan’s prime minister had previously said that the agreed-upon ceasefire covered “everywhere including Lebanon”.
JD Vance warns Iran to act in good faith in 'fragile' ceasefire – video
The
ceasefire process was clouded in uncertainty after Iran released two
different versions of the 10-point plan intended to be the basis for
negotiations, and which Trump said was a “workable basis on which to
negotiate”.
In the version released in Farsi,
Iran included the phrase “acceptance of enrichment” for its nuclear
program. But for reasons that remain unclear, that phrase was missing in
English versions shared by Iranian diplomats to journalists.
Pakistan
has invited the US and Iran to talks in Islamabad on Friday. Tehran
said it would attend, but Washington has yet to publicly accept the
invitation.
In a telephone call with Agence
France-Presse, Trump said he believed China had persuaded Iran to
negotiate, and said Tehran’s enriched uranium would be “perfectly taken
care of”, without providing more detail.
In
the two-week ceasefire, Trump said, he believed the US and Iran could
negotiate over the 10-point proposal that would allow an armistice to be
“finalized and consummated”.
“This will be a
double sided CEASEFIRE!” he continued. “The reason for doing so is that
we have already met and exceeded all Military objectives, and are very
far along with a definitive Agreement concerning Longterm PEACE with
Iran, and PEACE in the Middle East.”
Iran’s foreign minister, Abbas Araghchi, issued a statement
shortly after Trump’s announcement saying Iran had agreed to the
ceasefire. “For a period of two weeks, safe passage through the Strait
of Hormuz will be possible via coordinating with Iran’s Armed Forces,”
he wrote.
Jubilation on streets of Tehran as Iran and US agree two-week ceasefire – video
Oil prices dived, stocks surged
and the dollar was knocked back on Wednesday as a two-week Middle East
ceasefire sparked a relief rally, fueled by hopes that oil and gas flows
through the strait of Hormuz could resume.
Despite
the provisional ceasefire, attacks continued across the region in the
hours after Trump’s announcement. Before the deadline, airstrikes hit
two bridges and a train station in Iran, and the US hit military
infrastructure on Kharg Island, a key hub for Iranian oil production.
The
sudden about-face will allow Trump to step back as the US war in Iran
has dragged on for five weeks with little sign that Tehran is ready to
surrender or release its hold on the strait, a conduit for a fifth of
the global energy supply, where traffic has slowed to a trickle.
Trump
had earlier rejected the 10-point plan as “not good enough” but the
president has set deadlines before and allowed them to pass over the
five weeks of the conflict. Yet he insisted on Tuesday the ensuing hours
would be “one of the most important moments in the long and complex
history of the World” unless “something revolutionarily wonderful”
happened, with “less radicalized minds” in Iran’s leadership.
News of the provisional ceasefire deal was welcomed but with a note of caution elsewhere.
Iraq’s foreign ministry called for “serious and sustainable dialogue” between the US and Iran
“to address the root causes of the disputes”, while the German foreign
minister, Johann Wadephul, said the deal “must be the crucial first step
towards lasting peace, for the consequences of the war continuing would
be incalculable”.
In Australia, the government warned that the latest developments would not necessarily mean the fuel crisis is over.
Oil prices fell as traders bet that the reopening of the strait of
Hormuz would help fuel supply resume, but the energy minister, Chris
Bowen, told reporters Australians should “not get ahead of ourselves”.
He
said: “People shouldn’t take today’s progress and expect prices to
fall. We welcome progress, but I don’t think we can say the [strait of
Hormuz is] now open.”
A spokesperson for New
Zealand’s foreign minister, Winston Peters, welcomed the “encouraging
news” but noted “there remains significant important work to be done to
secure a lasting ceasefire”.
Japan said it
expected the move to result in a “final agreement” after Washington and
Tehran begin talks on Friday. Describing the ceasefire as a “positive
move”, the chief cabinet secretary, Minoru Kihara, said Tokyo wanted to
see a de-escalation on the ground in the region, adding that the prime
minister, Sanae Takaichi, was seeking talks with the Iranian president,
Masoud Pezeshkian.
A temporary end to
hostilities will come as a relief to Japan, which depends on the Middle
East for about 90% of its crude oil imports, most of which is
transported through the strait of Hormuz.
South
Korea’s ministry of foreign affairs said it hoped “negotiations between
the two sides will be successfully concluded and that peace and
stability in the Middle East will be restored at an early date”, as well
as wishes for “free and safe navigation of all vessels through the
strait of Hormuz”.
Sen. Ed Markey (D-MA) joins MS NOW’s Lawrence O’Donnell to discuss how Donald Trump’s threats of genocide in Iran are grounds for impeachment and removal. “Republicans in Congress are spineless,” says Sen. Markey but encourages Congress to come together to remove Trump from office.
» Subscribe to MS NOW: / @msnow
» Subscribe to MS NOW’s We the People Newsletter for exclusive content from your favorite MS NOW anchors. Sign up now for free at https://ms.now/joinus
MS NOW is the go-to destination for domestic and international breaking news, and best-in-class opinion journalism. For more context and news coverage of the most important stories of our day click here: https://www.ms.now/#iranwar#warcrimes#impeachment
Transcript
0:02
2 seconds
Today, Pope Leo, in a rare statement in English so Donald Trump could understand him,
0:08
8 seconds
he He directed a statement at Donald Trump that tried to convince Donald Trump to not go through
0:17
17 seconds
with his threatened war crimes today against Iran.
0:23
23 seconds
Asking all people of goodwill to search always for peace and not violence,
0:29
29 seconds
to reject war, especially a war which many people have said is an unjust war, which is continuing to
0:38
38 seconds
escalate and which is not resolving anything.
0:44
44 seconds
Let's remember especially the innocent children the elderly sick so many people who have
0:52
52 seconds
already become or will become victims of this continued warfare and to remind all that attacks
1:00
1 minute
on civilian infrastructure is against international law but that it is also a sign of the hatred, the division,
1:09
1 minute, 9 seconds
the destruction that the human being is capable of and we all want to work for peace.
1:17
1 minute, 17 seconds
Also today our next guest, Democratic Senator Ed Markey of Massachusetts who has voted twice to stop Donald Trump's illegal war
1:24
1 minute, 24 seconds
in Iran said, quote, we have a warmonger in the White House.
1:28
1 minute, 28 seconds
He
has threatened war crimes on an apocalyptic scale and appears eager to
commit them. The House and Senate must return to session.
1:36
1 minute, 36 seconds
The House must pass Articles of impeachment.
1:38
1 minute, 38 seconds
And then the Senate must vote to convict and remove the president or the cabinet and vice president with congressional
1:46
1 minute, 46 seconds
concurrence must invoke the 25th amendment and remove Trump.
1:50
1 minute, 50 seconds
His threats cannot be dismissed as mere rhetoric.
1:53
1 minute, 53 seconds
This is as grave a moment as the world has faced in the nuclear era.
1:58
1 minute, 58 seconds
Joining us now is Democratic Senator Ed Markey of Massachusetts.
2:02
2 minutes, 2 seconds
Senator, thank you very much for joining us tonight. What is your reaction to Donald Trump, as Iran puts it,
2:10
2 minutes, 10 seconds
surrendering now and stopping his war, leaving Iran in control of the Strait of Hormuz?
2:18
2 minutes, 18 seconds
Yeah, Donald Trump has surrendered, not the Iranians.
2:23
2 minutes, 23 seconds
And what he has been doing over the last several days is an impeachable offense.
2:31
2 minutes, 31 seconds
He has threatened a genocide against the nation. He has threatened to end a civilization.
2:38
2 minutes, 38 seconds
He has threatened to use nuclear weapons against a country that does not have nuclear weapons.
2:45
2 minutes, 45 seconds
All of these are impeachable offenses, and he must be brought to justice.
2:52
2 minutes, 52 seconds
The House and Senate should be brought back into session.
2:56
2 minutes, 56 seconds
There should be articles of impeachment brought against him by the Democrats in the House of Representatives.
3:03
3 minutes, 3 seconds
We need to make Donald Trump accountable for what he has just done. In the name of the American people.
3:11
3 minutes, 11 seconds
And I think this is going to be a defining moment for the Congress, for the American people.
3:20
3 minutes, 20 seconds
We cannot allow Donald Trump, in control of nuclear weapons,
3:25
3 minutes, 25 seconds
to
be invoking this madman theory of the destruction of a civilization in
the name of the American people without him being BROUGHT TO
ACCOUNTABILITY.
3:37
3 minutes, 37 seconds
THE IMPEACHMENT PROCESS MUST BEGIN.
3:41
3 minutes, 41 seconds
WE HAVE REPORTS TONIGHT OF OVER 50 HOUSE DEMOCRATS AGREEING WITH YOU ON this.
3:48
3 minutes, 48 seconds
Over 20 Senate Democrats agreeing with you on exactly this.
3:53
3 minutes, 53 seconds
I want to read you the one statement we have about this from a Senate Republican, and that's Senator Lisa Murkowski,
4:00
4 minutes
every other Senate Republican has avoided saying a word about it.
4:04
4 minutes, 4 seconds
She
said the president's threat that a whole civilization will die tonight
cannot be excused away as an attempt to gain leverage in negotiations
with Iran.
4:12
4 minutes, 12 seconds
This type of rhetoric is an affront to the ideals of our nation,
4:16
4 minutes, 16 seconds
has sought to uphold and promote around the world for nearly 250 years.
4:19
4 minutes, 19 seconds
It undermines our longstanding role as a global beacon of freedom and directly endangers Americans, both abroad and at home.
4:28
4 minutes, 28 seconds
But
the rest of your Republican Senate colleagues are absolutely silent
along with the Republican Speaker of the House who did not
4:35
4 minutes, 35 seconds
say one word about this today. My Republican colleagues are spineless.
4:42
4 minutes, 42 seconds
They are in a witness protection program.
4:47
4 minutes, 47 seconds
It's almost like the invasion of the body snatchers.
4:51
4 minutes, 51 seconds
You look at them, they look like the same human beings. But inside, it's just MAGA control, Trump control.
4:57
4 minutes, 57 seconds
They
just don't have the courage to stand up when something which is clearly
a violation of everything that our country is supposed to stand for,
5:07
5 minutes, 7 seconds
uh, is being compromised by Donald Trump.
5:11
5 minutes, 11 seconds
And the question is, for them, it's 40 days later. Are we better off today than we were 40 days ago?
5:19
5 minutes, 19 seconds
No.
5:20
5 minutes, 20 seconds
The Iranian army now controls the Straits of Hormuz and the price of oil for the world,
5:27
5 minutes, 27 seconds
and they can charge a fee for every ship which is going through. Do we control the uranium? No, we do not.
5:36
5 minutes, 36 seconds
The Iranian army still controls the enriched uranium that could hold the world hostage. Are the Iranian people free?
5:44
5 minutes, 44 seconds
No, they're terrified of our country, that we would blow up their bridges, their schools, their civilization.
5:53
5 minutes, 53 seconds
And has there been regime change? No, there has not.
5:57
5 minutes, 57 seconds
All we have is Ayatollah Sr. replaced by Ayatollah Jr.
6:01
6 minutes, 1 second
So, all of this has occurred in the last 40 days without a peep from the Republican leadership in our country.
6:11
6 minutes, 11 seconds
And
there is something fundamentally wrong with our democracy when Donald
Trump can threaten the use of nuclear weapons to destroy
6:19
6 minutes, 19 seconds
a civilization and the Republican Party refuses to respond at all.
6:26
6 minutes, 26 seconds
And the American people are going to pay an Iran war tax every day. They go to the pump. It's Trump at the pump.
6:33
6 minutes, 33 seconds
It's up a buck a gallon. It's It's not going away. We just have a two-week reprieve,
6:38
6 minutes, 38 seconds
and it's going to ripple right through our economy.
6:40
6 minutes, 40 seconds
And
ultimately, the voters are going to be coming with pitchforks for
Republican House and and Senate members this election in November.
6:51
6 minutes, 51 seconds
Massachusetts Senator Ed Markey,
6:52
6 minutes, 52 seconds
thank you very much for joining our coverage tonight. Thank you.
6:56
6 minutes, 56 seconds
And coming up, the top Democrat on the House Armed
On Tuesday morning, President Donald Trump began a post
on his social media platform Truth Social by writing, “A whole
civilization will die tonight, never to be brought back again.” Trump
continued in the post, “I don’t want that to happen, but it probably
will.”
The president’s post and other recent threats
come in the lead up to an 8 p.m. Tuesday deadline that he has imposed
on Iran to reach a deal to open the Strait of Hormuz. The threats have
led to concerns from figures including former Fox News Host Tucker Carlson and Anthony Scaramucci,
the short-lived White House communications director turned Trump
critic, 0f a potential nuclear strike against Iran if the president is
unable to open the strait through conventional weaponry and diplomacy.
I asked the White House Tuesday morning if the president is mulling
the use of nuclear weapons and if his apocalyptic Truth Social post is
intended to convey such a threat. Six minutes later, at 11:19 a.m.
eastern time, the White House press office declined to rule out the use
of nuclear weapons. Instead, an unnamed official wrote, “We refer you to
the President’s TRUTH on this inquiry.”
In a follow-up email, I wrote that the Truth Social post in question
is ambiguous and that I would write in this article that “the White
House press office declined to comment on whether the president is
considering a nuclear attack on Iran,” and that it instead directed me
to a post that threatens the imminent death of an entire civilization.
I also asked if the White House would like to provide additional
comments or a statement. Two minutes later, at 11:45 a.m., the White
House shared a statement attributable to press secretary Karoline
Leavitt. “The Iranian regime has until 8PM Eastern Time to meet the
moment and make a deal with the United States,” Leavitt said. “Only the
President knows where things stand and what he will do.”
The responses from the White House press office were different from
an earlier tweet from its rapid response team that criticized a
Democratic account for saying that Vice President JD Vance had implied
on Tuesday that Trump was considering using nuclear weapons. “Literally
nothing [Vance] said here ‘implies’ this, you absolute buffoons,” the
rapid response team wrote.
The threat by Trump on Tuesday is yet another escalation from the
president in the lead up to his imminent deadline for opening the Strait
of Hormuz. On Easter Sunday, Trump wrote
that “Tuesday will be Power Plant Day, and Bridge Day, all wrapped up
in one” before adding “Open the Fuckin’ Strait, you crazy bastards, or
you’ll be living in Hell.” The language of the post suggested that Trump
is considering using conventional weapons to target civilian
infrastructure, which is itself a war crime. Trump said on Monday about Iran, “The entire country can be taken out in one night, and that night might be tomorrow night.”
Some of Trump’s biggest backers, including conspiracy theorist Alex Jones, are now warning that the president is no longer fit to serve and should be removed from office by his cabinet. “25TH AMENDMENT!!!,” former Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene wrote in response to Trump’s most recent threat. “We cannot kill an entire civilization. This is evil and madness.”